10 of Best Dog Subscription Box Review and Buyer’s Guide

Dog Subscription Box

Customization Offers

Organic or All Natural

Shipping To

Unique Offers


#1 Choice



View Product


  • Dog size

Not entirely


Guaranteed replacement of the item that your pooch does not like.

Double Your First BarkBox Free




  • Dog size
  • Frequency of delivery
  • Size of the box to receive
  • Kind of items to receive
  • Dog allergies specification


  • USA
  • Canada

Wide array of customization selection.

50% FREE bonus goodies with your 1st order


Surprise My Pet


  • Dog profile
  • Dog size



  • Also caters to small dogs that weigh less than 10 lbs.
  • Replacement of the items that your dog does not like.


Pet Treater


  • Allergy specification
  • Dog size



Guarantees that the items they deliver are from the USA or Canada.


The Farmer’s Dog

  • Dog’s basic profile like age, weight, breed and the like.
  • Recipes for shipment


but human graded.


Fresh and homemade food containing ingredients that are human-grade.

Pooch Perks

  • Dog size
  • Dog temperament
  • Allergy specification



  • Booster toy
  • Some dog foods are grain-free

Dapper Dog Box

  • Allergy specification
  • Dog size
  • Temperament
  • Frequency of delivery



Bowties or bandanas as part of the items

Bowties or bandanas as part of the items


  • Allergy specification
  • Dog’s weight


  • USA
  • Canada
  • Australia
  • United Kingdom

Specifically for the dogs who love to chew.





All natural and grain-free dog food.

Loot Pets





Most dog owners love their pooches a lot, which is the reason why they look for the best dog subscription box. They are willing to provide them with their needs and wants. For this reason, some of them subscribe to a dog subscription box that provides various items for dogs for a month.

Dog subscription boxes contain items that your pooches love such as dog treats and toys. They may also contain grooming items and other items for your dog.

Dog owners are free to customize the items in each box based on their dog’s breed, age, size, and more. To help you choose the best, here is a review of some of the best dog subscription boxes in the market for 2018.

Is Subscribing for a Dog Box Worth It?

Knowing if a dog subscription box is worth your time and money depend on your dogs’ preference and your spending habits. If you love spoiling your dog, and if you find yourself spending tons of money buying several items for your dog, trying to subscribe for a dog box will not hurt. The other reason on why you should subscribe for the best dog subscription box is when you see your pooch destroying its toys all the time.

What to Expect from Subscription Boxes for Dogs

Unlike humans, there are different breeds of dogs. Each breed varies greatly in size, strength, and temperament. For this reason, the subscription boxes for dogs also vary in terms of content.

Here are some of the things that you should expect:

Customization According to Size

Some dog subscription boxes can be customized based on the size of the dog. One example is the Surprise My Pet subscription box. Surprise My Pet provides a different set of items for smaller dogs and bigger dogs.

Other Customization Features

Some subscription boxes that provide the buyers the freedom to customize the items that they will receive. PupJoy is one example. You can specify the items that you will receive by providing your dog’s profile and preferences.

Some subscription box services will ask you about your dog’s temperament, allergies, environment, and gender.

Most of the time, a subscription box service that provides loads of customization options is more expensive than the others.

Origin of Products

Most of the items provided by a high-end subscription box come from or made in the USA, Canada, South America, and Australia. The others come from China. It is advisable to stay away from dog subscription box services that send items made in China.


The most common stuff that you will see inside a subscription box are dog toys, accessories, paraphernalia, treats, and chews. There are subscription boxes that cater to dogs that are hard chewers like the BullyMake and the BarkBox Super Chewer.

There are others that provide you more freedom to choose what kind of items that you will receive for your dog. One example is the Bullybundles.

Length of Subscription

The best dog subscription box provides a discount for longer subscriptions. Some services will ask you to pay in advance for a 12-month subscription. The others will hold your money and your promise to subscribe for a longer time.

Reasons Why You Should Get a Dog Subscription Box

Here are some reasons why you should decide to get a subscription box for your dogs:

  • The experts picked out the best products themselves. They choose products that are high-quality and natural.
  • Most of the time, the items are not readily available in pet shops or grocery stores.
  • It eliminates the need for transport or driving.
  • The total price of all the products in the box is just a fraction of their price if you buy them separately from stores.
  • Looking forward on what you are about to receive next feels exciting.
  • Most merchants offering dog subscription boxes support charities.
  • You support the local businesses in your home country.
  • The food options are healthy and organic.

List Down Companies That Offer Dog Subscription Box Services

Find the reliable ones with high ratings. After listing down these companies, visit their website. Read about the items that you will receive, the customization features, customer support services, shipping rate, and the like.

Remember that every pet subscription box service caters to the different needs of the dog. Compare the services that they are offering to what your pooch needs.

Observe and List Down Your Pet’s Profile

Before subscribing to any service, it is important that you should know your pooch first. Take note of your dog’s size, weight, and temperament. Is it the kind of dog that destroys things because it loves to chew? Is it the kind of dog that loves different kinds of treats? Is it allergic to chicken or beef?

You need to take note of these basic dog profiles because you will need it.

Observe Your Spending Habits

Do you always find yourself buying new stuff, toys, or treats for your dog? Take note how much are you willing to spend every month and put this into consideration.

Dog Subscription Box Selection Guide

Many companies offer dog subscription boxes to dog lovers all the time. All of them claim that they offer the best dog subscription box, but it is not true for all. This is because some may prefer other brands over others simply because of their preference in the items included in each box.

Other subscription box services only want your money and not your dogs’ satisfaction. For this reason, you should know how to select the best dog subscription boxes for your pooch.

10 of the Best Dog Subscription Boxes

#1 BarkBox

This box costs $29 per month and $19 per month if you subscribe for 12 months. The shipping is free, but they only ship to the United States.

The BarkBox subscription provides treats and toys that your pooches will love. It usually contains two all-natural treats and two innovative toys. A box contains four to six items. You can customize the box content that you will receive by selecting the size of your dogs.

It is deemed as one of the most popular and the best dog subscription box of its amazing offers. You can find that the items inside the box are of high-quality. Most of the items come from the USA or Canada. The some of the chews are also sourced from New Zealand, Australia, and South America.

Their products are free of corn, wheat, and soy. For this reason, you do not have to worry if the contents of the subscription box can cause allergy to your furry friend. Aside from that, they also have products for dogs that are allergic to chicken, turkey, and beef.  

The fun part of the BarkBox is that the boxes each have themes inspired by movies. They guarantee that you can return the product if in case your pooch does not like its content. Currently, they have more than 2 million subscribers.

They also have a BarkBox Super Chewer box that caters to chewer dogs. The products inside this box contain toys and treats that are not easily prone to breaking when chewed.

BarkBox is often being compared with the PupBox. In comparing the Pup Box vs. Bark Box, the difference is that the PupBox’s main market is for puppies. However, their services are not limited to pups. They also accommodate grown-up dogs too.

PupBox is more expensive than other options in the market, but its box also contains more items.


  • Offers a discounted price if you subscribe for more months
  • Can easily be ordered via SMS or online
  • Provides tracking info so you can monitor your delivery
  • Has an available app for Android and iPhone
  • Shipping is included in the subscription
  • Offers a discount for multiple dogs
  • Rescue organization donation
  • Made in Canada or USA
  • The website is user-friendly


  • Subscriptions are automatically renewed


#2 PupJoy

The PupJoy box costs $29 per month. A box contains organic treats and accessories. This box offers a personalized touch because you will have to indicate the profile of your dog and its preferences upon ordering. From the information you gave, you will receive a box that is tailored to your dogs’ needs.

You have to choose the size of the box that you want to receive for your dogs. The labels of the selection of boxes include Grande or Uno. You also have an option to choose what kind of items that you want your dog to receive, whether these are toys or treats.

You can specify if your dog has allergies so that PupJoy will give you something that is nutritious but safe for your dogs.

You can also choose if you want to receive the subscription box quarterly, bi-monthly, or monthly. Just like the others, PupJoy offers products that are grain-free, organic, and natural.

Moreover, a part of your purchase supports an animal rescue called the BISSELL Pet Foundation. This foundation funds more than 3000 organizations that rescue animals.

The PupJoy is especially recommended for dog owners whose pooches have a lot of preferences and allergies. Unlike the other subscription boxes, the PupJoy offers a number of customization features so you can tailor the box that your dog will receive and enjoy.

You are free to cancel your subscription anytime. It is also possible to get some pro-rated refund.


  • Various selections for customization
  • Freedom to choose the frequency of delivery
  • Superb customer support
  • User-friendly website


  • More expensive compared to other subscription boxes

#3 Loot Pets

The Loot Pets subscription box costs $19.99. Each box contains treats and toys that dogs will surely love.

Aside from the expected content, the box theme is based on fandom and mainstream movies to make it more interesting, just like what its parent company Loot Crate offers.

Sadly, the Loot Pets had to say goodbye to all its subscribers last December 2017. Their final box contained two treats, two toys, an accessory, and a charm

Here is what the final box contained:

  • Goodbye card
  • Hacker Snacks treats
  • 20-sided collar charm
  • Space Invaders 6-foot leash
  • Bacon-flavored Alex Flex Wrench toy
  • Iron Man designed plush toy
  • Two bags of Zom-Bone treats

#5 Pooch Perks

The Pooch Perks box costs $18.45 to $45 per month. It contains accessories, toys, treats, and additional stuff that will spoil your pooch. The items are made from the USA. The Fox Business dubbed it as America’s best.

The Pooch Perks values customer satisfaction and their customization feature. There is a wide range of customization features available to their services like the delivery frequency, toys selection, allergies, and size.

In addition, their box has a monthly theme to add to the excitement.

They have an extra toy called a booster, which you can get for an additional fee of $7.99. They offer a small sample box just in case you want to try their services first.

You also have an option to deliver their services as a gift. You can attach simple messages and items. Their products are all-natural.

The only downside of this subscription box service is that they charge separately for a shipping fee, unlike the others.

The Pooch Perks also donates to organizations that help abused and rescued dogs.


  • Made in the United States
  • Durable plush toys
  • Natural, non-GMO, grain-free, gluten-free, organic, and no human-made preservatives.
  • Offers 8 percent discount for a 12-month subscription
  • Human bakers made the treats that were already tested by dogs.
  • Toys’ durability was tested by dogs


  • Has an extra charge for shipping

#6 Dapper Dog Box

The Dapper Dog Box costs $29.99 per month, but it costs $22 per month if you avail of a 12-month subscription. Aside from natural dog treats and toys, the Dapper Dog Box also contains bandanas and bowties to make your dog look fashionable.

The average amount of items that your dog will receive is five: an accessory or chew, two toys, and two treats. Dapper Dog is proud to say that the products that they will send to you are organic and 100 percent natural.

Moreover, you can also let them know about your dog’s allergies so that they can customize your box. Aside from that, you can customize the box that your pet will receive based on its size and chewing style.

You can also customize the frequency of delivery. You have a choice to skip a month or cancel the subscription entirely.

Aside from their regular box, they also have a heavy chewers box available for chewer dogs. However, it costs $34.99, which is more expensive than the regular box

Moreover, with every box purchased, Dapper dog donates $1 to animal rescues every month.


  • Products do not contain soy, corn, or wheat
  • Organic and natural
  • Offers a wide range of customization features
  • Free replacement of items that your dog does not like
  • Made in the USA
  • Supports 12 rescue dogs for every purchase
  • Ships internationally


  • Automatic renewal of subscription
  • Additional $5 for power chewers
  • No available cat subscription box
  • No discounts for multiple dogs

#7 Surprise My Pet

This subscription box costs $30 per month and $26 per month for a 12-month subscription. Surprise My Pet is new to the market and was only launched in 2015. It does not only cater to dogs but cats as well. Like other subscription box providers, Surprise My Pet also provides treats and toys that are all-natural.

The toys are unique, and the box has a personal touch to it.  They guarantee that none of their items have ingredients made from China.

They have a guarantee called paw for paw which means that if your dog is not interested in one of the given treats, you can have this item replaced for free. You just have to send them an email.

Also, they support charities by donation. A portion of your payment for every purchase is donated to charities which include the Animal Rescue Foundation.

Surprise My Pet provides different items for dogs that weigh under 10 lbs. and those who weigh 10 lbs. to 20 lbs. Having said this, the Surprise My Pet box is the best dog subscription box for you if you have a tiny dog.

In addition, Surprise My Pet offers a feature in which you can request for a repeat item that your dog has loved from the previous box. You can simply avail this by checking it out using the Surprise My Pet Depo.

Surprise My Pet ships worldwide.


  • Box for small dogs available
  • Also offers a subscription box for cats
  • Part of purchase goes to charity
  • Guaranteed item replacement for free
  • Offers discounts if you are subscribed for several months


  • No customer support via phone
  • Customization feature for dog allergies not present
  • Automatic renewal of plans
  • No discount for multiple dogs

#8 Bullymake

The Bullymake box costs $39 per month and $31 for a 12-month subscription. Bullymake caters to dogs who love to chew. You can expect that their chewable toys are of high-quality and are not easily torn.

Bullymake sends subscription boxes which cater to the size of your dog. Thus, they have to know the weight information so that they will know whether to deliver big or small toys.

They guarantee that their products are tough and can resist the fangs of your dogs. As such, they provide a replacement for free if a toy they sent has been torn within 14 days after shipping.

However, they do not offer multi-pet discounts. If you own two dogs, for example, what you can only do is add a toy to your subscription for an additional $9 every month. On the positive note, you can customize what goes into the box if your dog has a picky taste.

You have the option to receive a box full of toys if your dogs are not fans of treats.

Bullymake ships internationally. There is no shipping cost if you order within the United States. If you are in Canada, the shipping cost will only be $8. However, if you come from the other parts of the world, the shipping cost will vary depending on your location.


  • Bullymake is mindful of dogs’ allergies.
  • Has a 14-day warranty for toys
  • Offers a wide selection of durable and high-quality toys
  • Offers to replace toys that do not fit your dog’s preference
  • Ships internationally
  • The frequency of subscription delivery is customizable.


  • Expensive compared to the others
  • Automatically renews subscription
  • Does not offer a discount for multiple dogs

#9 Pet Treater

Each Pet Treater box costs $24.99 per month. In every box, you will receive toys, accessories, treats, and other stuff like poop bags each month.

You can choose among three different sizes of box, depending on the weight of your dog.

Moreover, they also give a special treat for every first Pet Treater Box that you purchase.

Pet Treater ships only in the US.


  • USA or Canada-made treats
  • Customizes treats based on your dog’s diet restrictions
  • User-friendly website
  • Special requests are entertained
  • Pet Treater contributes to a shelter for every shipped box.
  • Offers cat boxes as well


  • Does not offer a discount for multiple dogs
  • Subscriptions are automatic renewed

#10 PawPack

Each PawPack box costs $29.99 per month and $24.99 per month for a 12-month subscription.

The PawPack is owned by The Gift Box. With this subscription box, you are assured that your dog will receive food and treats that are organic and nutritious. Aside from food, the box also includes toys.

Before The Gift Box received the total ownership of the PawPack, the main focus of this subscription box was to provide eco-friendly and all-natural products.

When The Gift Box gained ownership of this service, some changes already materialized. Although the food and treats are still nutritious and organic, some of its original features have been removed.

As of the moment, they do not offer customization services for food that can cater to your dog’s allergies. There is also currently no option wherein you can choose a box based on your dog’s size. Moreover, PawPack only ships within the United States.


  • Offers nutritious products
  • Pawpack supports charity
  • Gives a $10 incentive for every referral


  • Less variety of products
  • Customization feature that caters to dog allergies is unavailable
  • The website is not user-friendly

Some people do not have the time to run errands. If you are that kind of person, the most probable reason why you go to a store is only to buy necessities. As with this case, you also may not have the time to go to a pet shop and buy treats for your dogs.

For this reason, most people go for online services just to buy products at the comforts of their home. Now, you may already buy your dog some supplies with a bit of surprise through a dog subscription box.

It works the same way as the subscription clubs for humans. Therefore, the number of people looking for the best dog subscription box is also growing. With this review and buying guide, hopefully, you can choose a subscription box that will perfectly cater to your pet’s needs and preference.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here